Wednesday, April 22, 2015

Case Study: Renderings vs Reality at Casper College School of Music

In the course of designing the new School of Music building at Casper College, in 2011, we created several renderings to aid in our design decisions for the major spaces, to make sure they look & feel right.  These were also used to show the owner what they could expect as a final product, and also distributed to them to use as promotional materials to drum up support.

The program we used (the then-cutting edge Autodesk Revit 2011&2012,) allowed us (and our consultants) to model the entire building in the computer before anything was built, allowing us to more accurately visualize how the finished product will generally look.  There are several schools of thought in terms of renderings, but we generally strive towards accuracy, minimizing the amount of embellishment.   There are, of course, levels of detail that are not always present.  For example, often we don't need to spend time modeling the light switches and exit signs to get a good sense of the space, but in general, with a more accurate rendering, the client is made aware of the final appearance of the space, and if any problems are found early on, they can be addressed before they become expensive change orders during construction.

When the project was completed, HMS hired a photographer to document the same spaces.  See below for the comparison, to show how closely the renderings (created entirely in the computer while the site was a grass field) compared to the real world building, more than a year later.

Concert hall from back rear.  Rendering is on top, final picture below.  This rendering is from relatively early in the process, and there has been some subtle tweaking of the design during the final CD stage and construction, notably in the upper ceiling and wall panels, and the lower railings.
Concert hall from center.  This rendering has been updated, showing the revised railings, wall panels, and ceiling panels, changed during value engineering.

Instrumental Rehearsal hall.  Rendering is on top, final picture below.   Both views are from the back of the room towards the front, but are from opposite corners - the whiteboard is the same.  For reference, the room is more or less symmetrical, except for the window.  The curtain is adjustable, and can be opened or closed to suit the acoustics of the room.
Choir Room.  Rendering on top, final picture below.  Rendering is fairly accurate, other than missing furniture and curtains, and some slight material inaccuracies with the wooden slats at the top, the ceiling tile material, and the wall diffuser material.
Percussion Suite.  Rough rendering on top, final photo on bottom.   Views are from opposite corners of the same room, facing the same windows.  All the acoustic panels and casework is modeled correctly, although the same ceiling and wall diffuser material issues are present, and the carpet tile was laid in a slightly different pattern.  Notably, the curved acoustic hanging panels needed to be shifted slightly during construction.

Front Lobby.  Rendering at top, final image below.  All the elements are in place, minus the owner-supplied furniture.  The color balance differs slightly, with reality feeling brighter and fresher than the warm and dark rendering.
Main Stair.  Rendering at top, final photo below.  Note how the stair, railing, lights, and benches are all built more or less as drawn, except for a few finishes, selected later.
Upstairs Lobby  Rendering is on the top, with final photo on the bottom.  Geometry is essentially identical, along with colors.   There are only a few  special system and owner-supplied elements missing from the renderings, and the room in general "feels" darker than reality.

For reference, this building was modeled in then-cutting edge Autodesk Revit 2011 and 2012, and rendered in the same program, on our local computers.  Since then, we have continually improved our rendering technology and skills to create better and more-accurate renderings.


Wednesday, April 15, 2015

Mimosa Park Elementary School Celebrates 1 Year Past Substantial Completion


On Tuesday April 14th, Mimosa Park Elementary School celebrated 1 year since its new HMS-designed kindergarten wing was completed, ahead of schedule, by Percy J Matherne Contractor.  To commemorate this, we've completed and posted the final versions of the timelapse videos we took on our weekly visits, over the course of the construction of the project. Each image represents approximately 1 week of time elapsed, across a total of about 16 months, from December 2012 to April 2014.




We've also included our initial renderings at the beginning and the end, for comparison to the final product.   Note that the pictures have deliberately not been color-corrected until the final images, to see how the light changes as glass and electric lights are added and/or turned off.  Also, the building was too big to fit in the camera, so each of these pictures is an auto-stitched panorama, which sometimes leads to interesting artifacts at the seams.   These were deliberately left in to keep the images un-biased.

There are six timelapse videos of the same project in the playlist above.  Their individual links are:

Exterior View: http://youtu.be/8wOqRVIMgU4
Cafeteria from front door: http://youtu.be/ZCYMIY0GsYg
Cafeteria from front corner: http://youtu.be/cI1ncjmFF0w
Cafeteria from rear center: http://youtu.be/GSnedvUhvtE
Hallway from Cafeteria: http://youtu.be/U5qTnFEi4dg
Hallway towards Cafeteria: http://youtu.be/PYPQvtGGW_g

Thanks to St Charles Parish Public Schools and Percy J Matherne Contractor for working with us to make this building a reality.

More about the Mimosa Park Elementary New Kindergarten Wing
More about HMS-designed Schools and other Educational Projects
More about Mimosa Park Elementary School (via SCPPS)
More about St Charles Parish Public Schools
More about Percy J Matherne, Contractor
Check out our previous story about Mimosa Park Elementary, complete with fly-around, here.
Check out our previous story about Mimosa Park Elementary, complete with construction timelapse, here.
Check out all our previous stories about Mimosa Park Elementary, here.

Wednesday, April 8, 2015

HMS Reinforces Interior Design Department, Again!

HMS welcomes Rae Ann Famiglio to our interior design department!


Rae Ann came to us as a recent graduate of the Interior Design program at the University of Louisiana at Lafayette, and has already shown herself to be quite useful, helping with educational, commercial, ecclesiastical, and residential projects.  Along with Mary Beth, she is a vital part of HMS's Interior Design team.

More Info on Rae Ann Famiglio